Degradation Tests: My journey from 100% to 0%, and back from 0% to 100% | BMW i4 Forum
BMW i4 Forum banner

Degradation Tests: My journey from 100% to 0%, and back from 0% to 100%

1 reading
2.4K views 14 replies 9 participants last post by  Accident  
#1 ·
Quick update on my quest to better understand my remaining battery capacity. My recent charging history (Battery Degradation at 2 years and 50,000 miles | BMW i4 Forum) has shown some steady (but not alarming) degradation in the 2.5 years since I purchased my 2022 i4 M50. My most recent charging data shows my approximate usable battery capacity between 76-77 kWh, which indicates about 5%-6% degradation so far. Again, this isn't too surprising for a car with nearly 60,000 miles and 2.5 years of driving.

I decided to try the 100% to 0% degradation test (inspired by Kyle Conner: 100k mi Tesla Model 3 Performance Battery Degradation & 70-MPH Highway Range Test) to see what my i4 would deliver in terms of total energy on a controlled road test. The test isn't perfect, but it is a good way to estimate the total power drawn from the battery, although there is still a bit of unused energy at the bottom end, something I didn't want to test because I'm not driving my car to the point it doesn't move.

The testing occurred on a dry, sunny day (50 degrees F) without much wind. The test was a loop-style route from my home near Chapel Hill, NC, south on the interstate towards Wilmington, NC, then turned around at 55% SOC and headed back home on the same highway, with a constant speed of 70 mph.

I looped back home with some extra energy, so I burned off the remaining charge on the back roads near my house at 60+/- mph. I reached 0% SOC within a mile of my house and did a couple of back-and-forth trips on the rural highway near my house, driving about 4 miles or so below 0%. I wasn't worried about my range, as the power limiter slowly tapered and I had consistent power all the way back to my driveway (at this point I had only about 33% available power remaining...I wasn't willing to let it slide below that level).

I immediately plugged in and charged from 0% to 100% and noted the total power added (minus the typical losses from Level 2 charging).

Stats and calculations below:

100% - 0% test:
  • Total miles driven: 238.7 miles
  • Average efficiency: 3.15 mi/kWh (note: my average efficiency was bouncing between 3.1 and 3.2 during the final miles of my trip, so figured 3.15 was more representative of the total trip efficiency)
  • Estimated battery capacity: 238.7 mi / 3.15 mi/kWh = 75.8 kWh
  • Based on a new car usable capacity of 81.5 kWh, my estimated degradation is 7%
0% - 100% test:
  • Energy added: 78.7 kWh (adjusted for average Level 2 loss of 5.4%)
  • Based on a new car usable capacity of 81.5 kWh, my estimated degradation is 3.5%
Both tests yielded significantly different results. If I average the two tests, my degradation is 5.25%, which lines up pretty well with my long-term charging data. I strongly believe the 0%-100% charging test underestimated my degradation, and the 100%-0% test overestimated the degradation because I clearly had more miles left in the car. I think it's safe to say I'm solidly between 5% and 6% degradation at this point, and these two tests provide higher confidence as to my upper/lower bounds of actual degradation.

Image


Image
 
#6 ·
That's an interesting experiment and fairly good results imo for c60k miles.

Out of curiosity, I asked an AI bot (Gemini) what the figure is for an ICE engine, and got the following answer.
 

Attachments

  • Like
Reactions: BadgerGreg
#8 ·
Based on a new car usable capacity of 81.5 kWh
According to the UK BMW site technical data, the capacity for the M50 is 81.1 kWh (they also quote i4 eDrive as 81.3, which I find odd as I thought the battery was identical). BMW Media release in 2021 quoted 80.7 kWh, which was my understanding when I ordered my car. Canadian press release in 2021 quotes 81.5 kWh.

Which figure you choose doesn't make a massive difference to working out degradation but it would be nice if BMW could make their mind up!
 
  • Like
Reactions: BadgerGreg
#10 ·
According to the UK BMW site technical data, the capacity for the M50 is 81.1 kWh (they also quote i4 eDrive as 81.3, which I find odd as I thought the battery was identical). BMW Media release in 2021 quoted 80.7 kWh, which was my understanding when I ordered my car. Canadian press release in 2021 quotes 81.5 kWh.
I’ve seen variances in the net capacity number , but haven’t seen much variance in the gross capacity number (83.9kWh). The net capacity number is more of a soft number anyway given it’s software limited by the BMS.
 
#14 ·
I believe the usable battery capacity is slightly different depending on the market. I don’t have a link, but some of the early reviews in 2021 mentioned the difference. We would have to look at the regional press release to know the actual difference.
 
#15 ·
Image

100% - 0% test:
  • Total miles driven: 238.7 miles
  • Average efficiency: 3.15 mi/kWh (note: my average efficiency was bouncing between 3.1 and 3.2 during the final miles of my trip, so figured 3.15 was more representative of the total trip efficiency)
  • Estimated battery capacity: 238.7 mi / 3.15 mi/kWh = 75.8 kWh
  • Based on a new car usable capacity of 81.5 kWh, my estimated degradation is 7%
Great test! You can also check the app for an estimate of the energy used for the drive, and change the efficiency units to watts/ mile to reduce the rounding errors.