Long time viewer - New Member | BMW i4 Forum
BMW i4 Forum banner

Long time viewer - New Member

3 reading
56 views 2 replies 2 participants last post by  GDOG  
#1 ·
Thought I might as well join, as I have been reading this forum since before my car was delivered back in 2023.

A lot of great content here, but sometimes I feel I could add to the conversation, but of course have not been able to.

I have a Brooklyn Grey eDrive 40 M-Sport and absolutely love it.

I've driven just over 67000km so far and averaged just over 15kW/100km (about 4.1 miles/kWh for most of you I think).

I'm in New Zealand, so we have fairly mild weather, but it's not flat and we get lots of rain.

Only had one bad day since owning it.
When only a few months old I was driving along the motorway and a truck ahead was dumping stones all over the place. Every other car was re-flinging the stones, so there was nowhere to go. Was like a hail storm.
Later as traffic slowed, I though I might be able to get past, but my lane stopped and the guy behind hit me in the back - great! both ends in the space of a few minutes.

New lights, bumper, windscreen and rear diffuser (that was only deeply scratched) Mirror caps and bonnet re-painted.
$20k+ in damage.
Luckily the truck driver accepted fault and it was all done on insurance with brand new parts, so all good.
Got PPF after that.

Originally my car came with the Hankook S1 Evo 3 tyres. They were efficient, but terrible to drive on - When cornering I had no idea if my car would follow the curve or go into the ditch.

Due to roadworks ripping one of my rears (2am in the middle of nowhere), I ended up with Michelin PS5s on the back as that was all that was available at the time.

This totally transformed the drivability of the car - it's awesome!, but at a loss of efficiency, that even now that they are needing replacement never fully returned.

Looking at possibly going for the Goodyear Eagle F1 Assymetric 6, because they seem to be more efficient than the PS5s, and similar performance - anyone tried them yet?
 
2023 BMW eDrive 40 M-Sport owns
Brooklyn Grey
#3 ·
I think the BMW Star rated version is a dry handling tuned version.
I saw a comparison chart and it fell short in every other aspect compared to the non star version. Possibly that was the PS4S though...? Need to go back and check.
To be honest the BMW star is not important to me. BMW will tune for their priorities - not necessarily mine.
I ran the PS4 and PS4S on the Merc, so did not appreciate their efficiency, but agree that they were both in a different league handling wise to the Hankooks.
The PS5 replaced the PS4 (better life and handling apparently), but I can definitely say on the i4, the PS5 is not as efficient as the Hankooks, though in ALL other aspects way better.
The PS4 is still available, so if they are more efficient than the PS5, I might give them a go.
I was looking at the Goodyear Eagle F1 Assymetric 6 (crazy long name..), as it looks to have great handling, similar life to the Michelins, but better efficiency. Sadly though in NZ for some reason they are more expensive.

Thanks.